- Cowlesville [ Bennington Town ]
- Folsomdale [ Bennington Town ]
- Silver Lake Institute Historic District [ Castile Town ]
- Java Village [ Java Town ]
- North Java [ Java Town ]
- Dutch Hollow [ Sheldon Town ]
- Johnsonburg [ Sheldon Town ]
- Sheldon Center [ Sheldon Town ]
- Sheldon [ Sheldon Town ]
- Strykersville [ Sheldon Town ]
- Varysburg [ Sheldon Town ]
- Monument Circle Historic District [ Warsaw Village ]
- Wyoming Village Historic District [ Wyoming Village ]
- Attica Center [ Attica Town ]
- Bennington [ Bennington Town ]
- Bliss [ Eagle Town ]
- Buffalo Corners [ Perry Town ]
- Burke Hill [ Perry Town ]
- Chace [ Castile Town ]
- Covington [ Covington Town ]
- Cowlesville [ Bennington Town ]
- Dale [ Middlebury Town ]
- Danley Corners [ Bennington Town ]
- Dutch Flats [ Orangeville Town ]
- Eagle Center [ Eagle Town ]
- East Arcade [ Arcade Town ]
- East Bennington [ Bennington Town ]
- East Koy [ Pike Town ]
- Halls Corner [ Orangeville Town ]
- Hardys [ Gainesville Town ]
- Harris Corners [ Sheldon Town ]
- Hermitage [ Wethersfield Town ]
- Highland Glen [ Bennington Town ]
- Howes [ Eagle Town ]
- Java Center [ Java Town ]
- Lagrange [ Covington Town ]
- Lamont [ Pike Town ]
- Martinsville [ Warsaw Town ]
- Newburg [ Gainesville Town ]
- North Gainesville [ Gainesville Town ]
- North Sheldon [ Sheldon Town ]
- Oatka [ Warsaw Town ]
- Orangeville Center [ Orangeville Town ]
- Pearl Creek [ Covington Town ]
- Peoria [ Covington Town ]
- Perry Center [ Perry Town ]
- Pike Five Corners [ Pike Town ]
- Portageville [ Genesee Falls Town ]
- Punkshire Corners [ Arcade Town ]
- Rock Glen [ Gainesville Town ]
- Saltvale [ Middlebury Town ]
- Sierks [ Attica Town ]
- Silver Lake Junction [ Gainesville Town ]
- Smiths Corner [ Wethersfield Town ]
- South Attica [ Attica Town ]
- South Warsaw [ Warsaw Town ]
- Southburg [ Java Town ]
- Sucker Brook [ Perry Town ]
- West Middlebury [ Middlebury Town ]
- West Perry Center [ Perry Town ]
- West Perry [ Perry Town ]
- Wethersfield Springs [ Wethersfield Town ]
- Wing [ Eagle Town ]
- Wrights Corner [ Middlebury Town ]